What the research shows
In a randomized study of 61 people with mild to moderate eczema, a cream with 1 percent colloidal oatmeal was compared with a standard moisturizer for 14 days. Eczema severity scores fell by about half in the oat group. Both creams improved hydration, and only the oat cream also improved barrier function and skin pH. Two smaller studies without a comparison group found itch eased right after the cream was applied topically.
Most of this research was run by one manufacturer, and the studies are small and short. They are genuine results, and they agree with each other.
What to look for on a label
Colloidal oatmeal, oat extract and oat oil
Colloidal oatmeal is the whole grain, milled fine, carrying the starches, beta-glucan, avenanthramides, proteins and fats together. Oat extract is a liquid that draws out some of those compounds, depending on how it was made. Oat oil carries mainly the fats. Each can be a good ingredient. Only colloidal oatmeal is recognized by the FDA as a skin protectant, and it is the form the eczema trials tested.
The names it goes by
On a skin protectant, colloidal oatmeal is listed under Active Ingredients in a Drug Facts box, with its percentage. On cosmetic lists it usually appears as Avena Sativa (Oat) Kernel Flour, which does not always confirm the colloidal grade. The FDA minimum is 0.007 percent and the eczema trials used 1 percent, which means a printed percentage tells you more than oats pictured on the packaging.
Where it sits in your routine
Most colloidal oatmeal products are creams or lotions, which go on as your moisturizer step. A colloidal oatmeal cleanser replaces your usual cleanser, with your moisturizer after it. A bath powder is for the body.
What works best with colloidal oatmeal
Colloidal oatmeal is not an exfoliant or an acid and does not need a particular pH to work, which means it does not interfere with anything else in your routine. It pairs especially well with ceramides, which replace the barrier fats your skin is short on, and with glycerin, which draws water in for the oat film to hold. It is also worth using on the nights you use a retinoid or an exfoliating acid, when your barrier is under the most strain.
Sunscreen every morning, reapplied through the day. UV damages the barrier you are working to repair, and colloidal oatmeal does not protect against it.